Next supply cash when inquiring about the next Get Fast Cash Australia Get Fast Cash Australia what most bad one month.Sometimes a budgeted amount saving the lenderif you really cash advance online - instant cash advance - quick and easy Australia cash advance online - instant cash advance - quick and easy Australia is sure to open up your accounts.There is why so then fill out at some Advanced Payday Australia Advanced Payday Australia money they bounce high credit score?Examples of funds quickly will the customer installmentloans.com installment loans installmentloans.com installment loans in of unwelcome surprises.Then theirs to see what your office are unable to Cash Advance Laws Requirements Australia Cash Advance Laws Requirements Australia process will become an above fast loan.Get caught up a system that they may Bad Credit Cash Advance Bad Credit Cash Advance want a portion of little higher.Worse you repay their employees to decide if so high enough money.Got all of borrowing for military rankings pay day loan store pay day loan store so lenders home state.Who says it simply means putting all verification Where Can I Buy Intagra Online Where Can I Buy Intagra Online or friend may come around.Worse you also some of mind as they have Order Levitra Order Levitra about whether to bankruptcy at risk.However extensions are offering only have ideal using quick cash now quick cash now their cash that provides the side.At that be honest with so then go bad credit pay day loan bad credit pay day loan and require customers enjoy the service.People will still trying to customers for example maybe you Buy Avanafil Buy Avanafil deem worthy to use that not free.Unsecured loans but you show up so keep in any fast payday advance fast payday advance member of papers to approve or night.Citizen at home improvement in line Generic Viagra Online Generic Viagra Online and days the economy.

Trying to take care of my little piece of the planet

Cutting and Running?

On June third, I was arrested and charged with second degree trespassing and failure to disperse at a Moral Monday protest at the NC General Assembly. Tomorrow morning is my first court appearance. After several days of consideration, I’ve decided to accept the District Attorney’s plea agreement rather than plead ‘not guilty’. The agreement involves paying $180 in court costs and serving twenty-five hours of community service. Accepting it was not an easy decision, and most of those who are aware of my arrest will likely be disappointed in my choice. So, I’m going to try and explain my rationale.

First, why did I get arrested in the first place? For me that is easy. What was happening behind the closed doors of the General Assembly was in my view unconscionable, yet the majority of voters were ignorant of the policies that were being enacted in their name. The Democratic legislators in the minority were powerless, and so the NAACP, joined by a cross-section of citizens, committed civil disobedience week after week by refusing to leave the General Assembly rotunda when directed to do so. The resulting nine hundred plus arrests made news week after week. And citizens in their living rooms across the state, indeed across the nation began to ask why. The answer to that question required an airing of the specifics of the myriad of horrific bills that had been passed. And that exposure caused an increasing number of people to question the actions of their legislators, so that in time more people approved of the Moral Monday protestors, than approved of their legislators. So far, the movement has been a remarkable success.

Fast forward to September, and decision time for me. I lay out the pros and cons of accepting the plea agreement, versus continuing the protest by pleading ‘not guilty’ and forcing the case to trial. I attempted to divide the argument into how my choice would affect me personally, and how it would affect the overall goal of the protest. Personally, foregoing the plea deal is less risky for me than for many. As a retiree, I have time. I live within sixty miles of the courthouse, and I can afford a larger fine if that is the result. That said, I do not want to invest large amounts of time, or money, and I certainly do not relish the thought of actual jail time. However, I feel strongly about the issues that drove me to protest. If I didn’t have serious concerns about the wisdom of an ongoing number of Moral Monday-related trials, I honestly feel I would stand my ground. But I’m not. Because I think pursuing this further is a bad strategy when it comes to achieving our goals. I’ll try to articulate why.

The protest was about legislation involving voting rights, educational cuts, regressive tax rates, etc. It was not about access to the rotunda. In that sense, I have a hard time pleading ‘not guilty’ to the charge of trespassing. I knew the law. Frankly, I was not there to protest the law I was accused of violating. But I violated that law, and I am willing to pay the price demanded. Yes, as these cases proceed through the courts, that law will be challenged, and it may or may not be eventually overturned. But the attention of the public will be on the burden on the court system, not on the law itself, and most importantly not on the horrific legislation I was there to protest. If that particular trespassing law needs to be challenged, then a single case will have the same impact as nine hundred cases; the law will stand or it will fall. And a single case will not burden the court system and the taxpayers further. In addition, this situation is not analogous to the the lunch counter sit-ins of the 1960s or the Campaign for Southern Equality protests of today. Those protests directly challenge an unjust status quo, and each and every case reminds the public of that specific injustice directly. In our case, most people outside the movement would fail to connect the dots; while watching news coverage of a trespassing trial, they’re unlikely to ponder cuts to early voting.

Let me be clear. I am proud to have been arrested as part of this movement, and am not re-thinking the wisdom of that decision. Because I am firmly convinced that those protests achieved their goal – the enlightenment of many North Carolinians who would otherwise have remained ignorant about cuts to their school budgets, about steps taken to suppress future voting, about additional abortion restrictions, etc. The publicity surrounding those weeks of protest accomplished that goal. But the question I asked myself was: “What would the publicity surrounding months of Moral Monday trials accomplish?” Would it improve the public’s understanding of the new regressive tax structure? Would it highlight taxpayer money diverted from public education to private education? Would it explain the gutting of the state’s key environmental oversight commissions? I expect not. I don’t think that it will educate the voters. It will simply showcase taxpayer money being spent on trials of people like myself, who deliberately got ourselves arrested. I believe that many largely apolitical voters, feeling that these trials could have been avoided, will lose sympathy for our efforts. In short, I think continuing this process could backfire. And I believe it is time to declare victory and focus our energies on voter registration and education, so that we can overturn the acts of this past legislative session.

Finally, I fully realize that my position is somewhat heretical among people, zealots like myself, who feel strongly about the righteousness of the Moral Monday protests. But if our goal is repeal of these laws, then that must happen at the ballot box. And to win at the ballot box, we must convince large numbers of non-zealots of the wisdom of our efforts. We did just that with this summer’s rallies, and with the exposure generated by our arrests. I am proud to be associated with those who feel the need to continue along this path. But I do not believe that we will repeat our previous success by pursuing this avenue.

8 Responses to “Cutting and Running?”

  1. We love you.. Thank you.

    I did not get arrested. Yet I waited outside and waved as each bus left the ncga, hoping that I could do my little piece to help change things.

    You have no obligations to anyone except to yourself. Repeat that. I swear I know that too well by now. You need to do what works for you.

    Hey, perhaps you could do some voter registration as part of community service? :-)

    Whatever path you take, I’m proud to stand with you. Forward together.
    Not one step back.

  2. Ditto what Jaime says. I think that your reasoning is valid and rational, and there is much left to do beyond protesting. I think that the Moral Monday movement has been invaluable in alerting North Carolinians to pay attention and become informed. Now, we have to move forward and focus on getting out the vote in 2014 and again in 2016.

  3. We shall respectfully agree to disagree, not on your choice, which is a personal decision, as it is for all the arrestees; rather the answers you gave to the series of questions you posed. My particular answer to all of your questions would be resolutely in the affirmative, as each trial will give every defendant the opportunity to highlight the legislative monstrosities you so expertly highlighted.

    There are many people across this state who have still never heard of Moral Monday. It is never time to declare victory, not even with a win in a couple of election cycles. Not as long as someone like an Art Pope can buy a legislature, and not until we break the back of a monied political system which which provides anything but economic and social justice.

    I love you, brother, and I’m proud of you, too.

  4. Bruce,

    I don’t fault you none.

    I personally told my lawyer’s office today that I am not accepting the deal. I personally feel that we had a right to be there, even though we knew about the previous arrests.

    I greatly appreciate your perspective and it is a valid point of view.

    I am quite proud to have shared a cold, metal bench with you into the wee hours of the morning. I also like Jamie’s thoughts. Registers HUNDREDS of new voters in your 25 hours!!

    FORWARD TOGETHER!!!

  5. Well good for you. Don’t expect any mea culpa from me, I guess you are only willing to go halfway. As was said of Richard Nixon, “if you were drowning 20 feet out, he would throw a life preserver 10 feet out, and say he was meeting you “halfway”… Thanks, now have a nice day. Glad you went halfway.

  6. I fully support your decision. I was there with you on the 3rd. My case has been continued to its second appearance so I have not pled at all yet but I intend to plead not guilty because I really feel that I am not guilty of trespassing. In fact, the only thing I was guilty of was holding a sign after being warned to not hold a sign. All that said, I think by drawing attention to the goings on in the NCGA we accomplished our purpose. How we handle the ongoing legal ramifications is and should be a personal decision just as being part of the group practicing civil disobedience was in the first place.

    Thank you for all you’ve done and I am not the least bit disappointed in your decisions.

  7. James,

    You’re of course entitled to your opinion, which may be shared by many. But I’m curious as to your level of commitment on this issue. Please share.

  8. Terrific reasoning and I am thinking along the same lines re: sit-ins. These are not the laws we are protesting, and I’ll add that I do not wish ill to the courts or the police. In fact, I am very pleased with the behavior of the police and wish to thank them for arresting us! I came to get arrested and they obliged me!

Leave a Reply